top of page

Coming Out of the Textbook

Cynthia Ma
Oct 29
5 min read

October is LGBTQ+ History Month. 


LGBTQ+ History Month didn’t start in a government office or a corporate boardroom. It started in a classroom. In 1994, Rodney Wilson, a high school history teacher in Missouri, decided that LGBTQ+ history deserved its own month. He had noticed that his 800-page textbook contained no mention of LGBTQ+ people at all. Hundreds of pages of history, and an entire community was missing.


National Coming Out Day already fell on October 11. The month also marked the first and second marches on Washington for LGBTQ rights in 1979 and 1987. In 1995, the National Education Association, the largest teachers’ union in the United States, endorsed it. 


So, when someone says history month is “unnecessary,” remember it exists because a teacher opened his textbook and found a hole the size of a whole community.


For most of the last century, being part of the LGBTQ+ community wasn’t just frowned upon. It was a crime and a reason to be scrutinized. 


In Canada, homosexuality was a crime until 1969. In the 1960s, Everett Klippert was jailed as a “dangerous sexual offender” for consensual sex with other men. The Supreme Court upheld his sentence in 1967. The public outrage helped push Parliament to partly decriminalize gay sex in 1969, but Klippert stayed in prison until 1971. 


Meanwhile, the government was running what became known as the “LGBT Purge.” From the 1950s into the 1990s, the public service, the military, and the RCMP were directed to identify and persecute LGBTQ+ employees. In his 2017 apology, Prime Minister Trudeau described how they were spied on and hooked up to polygraph machines. 


In 1953, President Eisenhower of the United States signed Executive Order 10450, which made “sexual perversion” grounds for removal from federal jobs. An estimated 7,000 to 10,000 federal employees were fired or forced to resign in what’s now called the Lavender Scare. 


On February 5, 1981, nearly 200 Toronto police officers raided four gay bathhouses, breaking down doors and walls with crowbars and hammers and arresting nearly 300 men in an operation they called “Operation Soap.” More than 90 percent of the charges were eventually dropped, and Toronto police didn’t apologize until 2016. The raids also had a secondary effect nobody in power planned for: the community took to the streets, and the movement in Canada was galvanized.


Forty years, less one month, after Klippert began his second prison sentence, same-sex marriage became legal in Canada. The Civil Marriage Act passed in 2005, making Canada the fourth country in the world to allow it. Other milestones were reached even more recently: gender identity and gender expression were added to the Canadian Human Rights Act in 2017, and conversion therapy was criminalized in Canada in January 2022.


The Trevor Project’s 2024 national survey heard from more than 18,000 LGBTQ+ people ages 13 to 24.

  • 39% had seriously considered suicide in the past year, including 46% of transgender and nonbinary young people.

  • 12% had attempted suicide.

  • Half of those who wanted mental health care couldn’t get it.

  • 90% said recent politics had hurt their well-being.

The Trevor Project ties these jarring statistics to bullying, discrimination, and threats. Their research also found that LGBTQ+ young people with at least one accepting adult were 40% less likely to report a suicide attempt. Separate research found that having at least one LGBTQ-affirming space, especially a school, was linked to a 35% lower chance of a suicide attempt. 


In 2021, Egale Canada and university researchers released Still in Every Class in Every School, which surveyed more than 4,000 students in Grades 8 to 12 across Canada. Verbal harassment based on sexual orientation fell from 51% in 2011 to 42%. Progress is real, and it happened because people pushed for it.


However,

  • 64% of all participants heard homophobic comments daily or weekly at school.

  • 2SLGBTQ students were still far more likely to be bullied and less likely to feel safe than their peers.

  • 79% of trans students who experienced physical harassment said teachers and staff were ineffective at addressing it.

Look at the last one: the problem isn’t only what other students say. It’s what the adults don’t say. The earlier national survey in 2011 found that almost 10% of LGBTQ students had heard homophobic comments from teachers daily or weekly. Discrimination can be a joke nobody corrects or a silence that tells someone they’re on their own.


The same researchers found that when schools offer consistent, comprehensive support, students see “profound benefits” for their mental health, safety, and sense of belonging. 


“But isn’t this too political?”


Learning about history is not an agenda. I’m not trying to push a political ideology or a particular way of thought. It’s simply history. People use the word indoctrination when they don’t want to talk about this anymore. Indoctrination means teaching students what to believe and shutting down their questions. If that’s what a history lesson does, I’d be against it too. Instead, I believe that a history unit about Bayard Rustin organizing the March on Washington belongs in the same category as a unit on Rosa Parks. A unit on Canada’s apology for the LGBT Purge belongs next to the units on residential schools or the internment of Japanese Canadians. It’s about what governments did and how they were held to account.


Rodney Wilson’s textbook had 800 pages and no mention of LGBTQ people. That wasn’t neutral. Every textbook is a set of choices about who counts, and silence is one of those choices. A curriculum that erases people has an opinion too. It just never says it out loud. People say history month is “political.” But every textbook is political, because every textbook decides who counts. If learning could make someone LGBTQ+, then past generations raised on textbooks with zero mention of the community would have turned out differently. All the silence did was leave kids who were already here feeling like they didn’t exist. 


Asking questions is how real education works, and it’s the opposite of indoctrination.

Wilson put it simply: all history is relevant to every life, because who you are, what you feel, and who you love should never dictate your worth as a person. 


What can YOU do?


Sometimes learning about these things can feel overwhelming. Here are some simple steps you can do, starting today:

  • Learn one new story. Equality Forum features 31 LGBTQ+ icons, one for each day of October. Read one a day, or even one a week. The Library of Congress also has an LGBTQ+ studies resource guide if you want to delve deeper.

  • Mark the dates. National Coming Out Day is October 11, and Spirit Day, when people wear purple to stand against bullying, is the third Thursday of October.

  • Speak up. When a joke or a slur lands in the hallway, say something! Silence tells people it’s fine.

  • Be someone a classmate can talk to without worrying about how you’ll react.

Comments


Subscribe

for the latest from

the Sentinel Sun!

The Sentinel Sun

sentinel sun ig logo.png

The blog for all things Sentinel.

Written for Sentinel students, by Sentinel students!

ig logo.png

© 2022 the Sentinel Sun. Website by Alice Lee

bottom of page